Maryville College saw four players score in double figures, as the Scots used a 13-0 second-quarter run to win the Battle of the Scots, 82-70.
MC fell behind by five in the first quarter, as they fought their way back. Trailing 20-19 toward the end of the first, Varney bucketed a trey from Delaney Lowery to take a 22-20 lead after one quarter.
The Scots built on that shot, scoring the next 13 points of the game.
Lowery found a lay-in of her own, before Varney assisted McCurdy on a 3-pointer. Gardner and Shelby Hix both found jumpers before Covenant's Joanna Smith ended the rally.
Varney found her second trey off a Catherin Upshaw assist to extend the lead to MC's biggest of the game, 34-22, at the 6:06 mark of the second quarter.
Maryville extended their lead to as many as 15, before the Scots took a 44-33 lead to the break.
Covenant would shot 45 percent through the third quarter to outscore the Scots, 21-12, cutting Maryville's lead to just three. MC fought off the rally, as they made 14 free throws in the fourth for the conference victory.
Maryville (8-10, 6-3 USA South) was led by Wandell's 20-point, nine-rebound effort against the Georgian Scots. The post added three steals and two blocks, as she went 12-of-14 at the free-throw line.
McCurdy added 18 points on a stellar 6-of-10 effort from beyond the arc, while Gardner added 14 points, four assists and two boards. Varney added 13 points, seven rebounds, four assists and a steal in the win.
Shelby Hix had seven points off the bench, while Elsa Eckenrod added six points, six rebounds, three steals and an assist. Lowery had four points, three assists, a steal and a rebound for MC, as Upshaw had three assists.
The Scots shot 25-of-58 (43.1 percent) from the floor, as they notched 12 treys at a 46.2 percent clip. MC went 20-of-28 (71.4 percent) at the free-throw line, while Maryville had 15 assists on 25 made baskets for the game.
Covenant (5-12, 3-6) shot 31-of-76 (40.8 percent) from the floor, while only converting two of their 12 3-point attempts.
Bekah Walter had 17 points, while Smith added 12 points, six rebounds and three assists. Raquel Rosa had 10 points, eight rebounds and four steals to round out Covenant's double-digit scorers.
Maryville will return to action on Saturday and Sunday, Jan. 19-20. The Scots face Agnes Scott College at 2 p.m. on Saturday, before taking on Wesleyan College (Ga.). Tipoff for Sunday's Brittany Johnson Memorial Fund Game will be at 1 p.m.