Delivered a strong 2025-26 season for the Maryville College women's golf program, competing in all eight events and 17 rounds while recording three top-10 finishes and five top-20 finishes. McElhaney opened the season with a ninth-place finish at the Women's Knights Invitational after posting a two-round score of +22.

McElhaney continued her consistent play throughout the fall, highlighted by a fourth-place finish at the Pioneers Fall Invitational after a two-round score of +25. She also placed 23rd at the Montgomery Women's Intercollegiate and 42nd at the Chick-fil-A Invitational.

In the spring, McElhaney recorded three top-20 finishes, including a 17th-place finish at the Port City Classic, a 14th-place finish at The 2026 Currahee Cup, and a 16th-place finish at the GreyStone Classic. She closed the season with a standout performance at the SAA Conference Championship, finishing 21st overall after three rounds with a score of +25.

For the 2025-26 campaign, McElhaney posted:

• 8 events played
• 17 rounds competed
• 3 top-10 finishes
• 5 top-20 finishes
• Season-best finish: 4th — Pioneers Fall Invitational (+25)
• Low round: 78 — Montgomery Women's Intercollegiate
• Best 36-hole score: +18 (158) — Montgomery Women's Intercollegiate